We Don’t Leave Ourselves at the Door

I’ve been thinking about how much more teachers bring to a classroom than the subjects they teach, and how those experiences open possibilities for our students, and for each other.

We don’t leave our other lives at the door.

For me, a lot of what I bring comes from being a knitting designer and an unconventional published writer. I haven’t published a book yet, but my knitting patterns have been published, sold, and shared. I’ve written for my own blog and been paid by blogs, magazines, and other publications to write about knitting, teaching, parenting, and other things I care about. I write the stories and descriptions that go with my designs, market my work, and sell it.

That experience shapes how I teach writing. But my experience as a teacher also shapes how I write.

And I make mistakes, in both writing and knitwear design. My students get to see that process happen in real time, often in math, ha! We find the mistake, figure out what needs to change, make the correction, and keep going. I think it matters to let students see that mistakes are part of creating, learning, and figuring things out, and that we can handle them with a little grace.

I absolutely want my fifth graders to do well on their writing assessments. I care about data. I care about scores. I want my students to know how to organize their ideas, develop their thinking, choose their words carefully, and write for an audience.

But I also know that a score is only one picture of a writer.

I know this because I write for a living. My writing has a voice and a style that are recognizable as mine. People read it, use it, and pay me for it. Does all of my writing fit neatly into a fifth-grade rubric? Probably not.

And yet, here I am, writing.

That doesn’t make the rubric unimportant. Quite the opposite. It gives me another perspective on what the rubric can and cannot tell us. In the real world, writing has an audience. It has to communicate, connect, teach, persuade, entertain, or simply make someone want to keep reading.

There is room for the standards, and there is room for the person behind them.

My knitting brings another piece of the real world into my classroom.

Knitwear design is basically engineering with string, but it is also creative fashion. I’m designing something that has to look and feel a certain way while also making the numbers work. When I design across 10 sizes, I use algebra, proportions, measurements, stitch and row counts, and problem solving to create something that actually fits a human body.

The materials are different, but the thinking is surprisingly similar to engineering: measurements, relationships, variables, constraints, and solving for what you don’t know.

So when a student asks, “When am I ever going to use this?” I have a real answer.

I use math all the time. Writing is part of my everyday life too, along with creativity and problem solving. I’ve made a living from skills that students sometimes think only exist in a classroom.

And that matters to me.

I don’t just want my students to learn skills. I want them to see what those skills can become.

A student who loves writing might eventually discover that it can become a career, a business, a way to connect with people, or simply a way to make sense of the world. (Ahem.) Maybe math will lead another student toward designing, building, solving problems, or figuring out how to make something work. The things our students are interested in now may become part of who they are later, even if they can’t see that yet.

Then I look around at the teachers I work with and realize that they are doing the same thing in their own ways, intentionally and unintentionally.

The coach knows that getting better takes practice, feedback, and sometimes failing before you get it right. They also understand something I think we sometimes forget in school: movement can be part of how we learn. Physical activity can help students experience timing, balance, coordination, and persistence. A coach sees learning happen through the body as well as the brain.

An artist brings a different way of looking at the world. There is room to experiment, make choices, try something that might not work, and try again. Students learn that there isn’t always one right answer or one right way to create something.

And then there is the teacher who color-codes everything. It might look like a lot of colored pens and folders, but there is a whole way of thinking behind it. Color can reveal relationships, patterns, and connections that might otherwise get lost. That teacher reminds us that sometimes how information is presented can make a difference in how well we understand it.

A musician understands that making music is about much more than getting the notes right. Rhythm, timing, listening, emotion, practice, and patience all matter. So does knowing when to lead, when to follow, and how to express something you don’t yet have words for.

There are teachers who always seem to have the right book recommendation, storytellers who make an idea stick, scientists who keep asking how and why, and historians who remind students that what happens today usually has a story behind it. Some naturally think in facts and evidence, while others start with a problem and ask, “What do we know? What do we need? What can we try?” Either way, students are learning how to make sense of information and figure out what to do with it.

A mechanic brings another kind of knowledge. They can look at a machine, understand how the pieces fit together, figure out what isn’t working, and use their hands to make something work again.

That matters too.

And so does knowing how to understand people.

A compassionate teacher notices the child behind the behavior. An observant teacher catches things that never show up in the data. An advocate knows when a child needs someone to speak up. A bridge-builder helps people understand one another.

Then there is the interventionist who knows that sometimes the best way to help a student is to start with what they already do well. They notice strengths that can easily get overlooked and build from there. They also understand that helping kids is rarely a one-person job. It takes communication, teamwork, flexibility, and a willingness to work together. There is something powerful about having a teacher who can see both the struggle and the potential at the same time.

The teacher who makes people laugh and knows that humor can make a hard day a little easier. Someone else can organize a mountain of information and somehow make it all make sense. Another teacher notices every little detail, strives for perfection, and pushes students to take pride in their work.

There are so many different ways of knowing things, and teachers carry those experiences into the classroom every day.

I value that more than I probably say. Some of the things I appreciate most about my co-teachers are the things I don’t naturally bring myself. I learn from how they think, how they solve problems, how they connect with kids, and how they notice things I might miss.

And our students are shaped by all of it.

Maybe one student discovers that knitting can involve algebra. Another realizes they are a writer, an artist, a scientist, or a storyteller. A book might change how someone sees themselves. A student who has always been told they are “too organized” might discover that organization is actually one of their strengths. Someone else may realize they are good with their hands and have a natural understanding of how things work.

And then there is the student who is just a really good friend. You know the one. They notice when someone is having a hard day. They make sure someone is included. They care about other people. They know how to bring people together.

I want that student to know that those are skills too. There is a kind of intelligence in understanding people and caring about them, even if it doesn’t show up on a report card. (Oh, I can go on and on about this one.)

We don’t know exactly what our students will become. That’s part of the privilege and the strange responsibility of teaching. We give them pieces of ourselves without knowing exactly where those pieces will show up later.

Maybe a student will remember something I said about writing years from now. Someone else may remember the teacher who encouraged them to keep going. Another might remember that a teacher took their questions seriously. Someone may simply remember being seen at a time when they thought no one noticed.

We may never know which moments mattered.

That is why I don’t think our students should all leave us looking the same.

We need writers and engineers, artists and coaches, musicians and scientists, organizers and storytellers, designers and entrepreneurs, mechanics and builders. We need people who notice details and people who see possibilities. There is room for the question-askers and the answer-finders, the people who understand numbers and the people who understand people. We need people who can work with their hands and people who can work with ideas.

So yes, I want my students to score well. I want them to learn the standards, demonstrate their skills, and feel proud of what they can do.

But I also want them to leave my classroom knowing that there are many ways to be smart. Their interests and ways of thinking matter. What they are good at now might eventually become something they never imagined.

Because we don’t leave our other lives at the door.

I bring my writing. I bring my knitting. I bring my nerdiness, my compassion, and my discipline.

The teachers around me bring their own versions of those things, along with music, art, books, science, stories, humor, warmth, structure, hands-on skills, and all the experiences that have shaped how they see the world.

Our students get to see all of those possibilities.

And maybe that is one of the most important things we give them. Not one definition of what success looks like, but enough different ways of thinking and being that they can begin to figure out who they might become.

Published by LovelybyLee

Amanda Lee is the Knitting Pixie (designer, dyer, knitter and owner) behind Lovely by Lee.

Leave a Reply